Saturday 15 September 2012

Who Made Big Money from Poor Indorians ? Shri Sandeep Manudhane Sir Or Shri Tarak Bajpai



Motivators or Cheaters ?

Speak Asia COO arrested in Rs 1,320 cr fraud case



 The first arrests have been made in the Rs 1320 crore Speak Asia fraud case. Mumbai police have arrested the online survey company's COO Tarak Bajpai and four other officials into custody. But the Singapore-based owner of the ponzi scheme company is still absconding.
"We have registered an FIR under cheating and criminal conspiracy (section 120b)," said Joint Commissioner of Mumbai Police (Crime) Himanshu Roy.
Based on a subscription model, Speak Asia collected Rs 11,000 from each member. The members were then paid for completing the surveys commissioned by various companies.
While many companies deny commissioning such surveys, the Mumbai police estimates that the total amount collected could well be over Rs 1320 crore. A case was also filed in the Economic Offences wing.
Once the scam was unearthed earlier in May this year, the members complained that they had not received the money promised as the company claimed its accounts were frozen. Speak Asia officials, however, claimed innocence.
"Their property must be attached and actions should be taken against other companies involved in similar activities under the Investor Protection Act," said BJP leader and complainant Kirit Somaiya.
The accused in the Pyramid scam have now been granted police custody till August 4 even as the money flow of Speak Asia is being closely looked into.
speak asia,
speak asia latest news,

speak asia scam,
speak asia genuine,
speak asia complaints,
speak asia online scam,
speak asia online pte. ltd
speak asia review,



A true picture of Proton B-school.....

1. Its run by Mr. Sandeep Manudhane who used to run PT education before making it a franchisse model . Now mentor of PT Univ. having 2 colleges in indore Proton n School of Business Marshals ( )

2. Proton is situated in front of the meter gauge line of Indore railway station in a crowdy place on top 2 floors of a commercial complex.

3. they are not giving a AICTE recognized PGDM (equivalent to MBA) ...its providing its own PGP certification ( not recognised ) + MBA ( DISTANCE LEARNING PROGRAME) frm some Vinayaka Mission Univ. ( never heard of it)

4. Its charging exubarant fees which is not in the line with the infra n facilities.

5. its not a residential prog.

6. They have 2 intakes .... and they admit ppl with grad % as low as 52% and some who to give their supplementary exams. ( i can name ppl )

7. the id of ppl on PG are all common and have a similar format of posts ie. they say how rigorous MBA @ PROTON is ... what new company came to their campus .... how summer placments have been and all companies are biggies.... not possible for a year old B-school n that too in this time.

8. Proton ppl can be seen marketing for PT outside CAT n various exams.

I am just giving real n factual info which i can prove.

Pl think bfore joining. I AM JUST AN AWARE STUDENT.
Dear so-called Shreyam
Someone brought your derogatory post on PROTON to my notice, and hence my reply. Thanks for making me join Pagalguy
While I can thrash and trash everything that you are trying to propagate by just suggesting www.proton.in/testimonials/ to all readers, I prefer giving a detailed reply.
I am Sandeep Manudhane, from PT universe, the promoters of PROTON. Going through this thread, I was dismayed to see the selective and jaundiced representation of facts.
While I respect peoples right to disagree with what PROTON students (Protons) claim about their institute, I expect them to do their research fully before publicly posting silly comments about an institute that has set new benchmarks in an impossibly short span of time in a place like Indore in Madhya Pradesh. Read on!
Allegation / Half-truth -
A true picture of Proton B-school.....
1. Its run by Mr. Sandeep Manudhane who used to run PT education before making it a franchisse model . Now mentor of PT Univ. having 2 colleges in indore Proton n School of Business Marshals ( )
Sandeep says - I still proudly run PT education across India, which has produced CAT Toppers for 5 years in a row (CAT Toppers = students with 100 percentile in IIM-CAT). We have 90+ centres now.
PROTON and SBM are great offerings from one of the finest group of educationists in India, whose institutions have trained more than 300,000 students in 16 years. Proof enough of the depth of work done.
Btw, PROTON has launched a fantastic campus in Ahmedabad in July 2009 as well. And SBM is at 3 places now Indore, Ahmedabad and Nashik!
Allegation / Half-truth -
2. Proton is situated in front of the meter gauge line of Indore railway station in a crowdy place on top 2 floors of a commercial complex.
Sandeep says Have you visited the campus personally Shreyam? You have conveniently omitted the most crucial facts, which I am obliged to bring to your kind notice. And I must thank you for giving me this opportunity.
> PROTON Indore is a 1 lac sq.ft modern construction. Most of it is airconditioned, with modern fitouts, and is completely wi-fi.
> PROTON Indore has an ultra modern auditorium with 300 seating capacity, and most modern teaching tools throughout the campus.
> PROTON Indore has 14 classrooms, 2 theatres, Board Room, and a fully functional office area which rivals an MNC office anytime.
> All campuses of PROTON (at present 2) are connected through real-time video-conferencing (how many other B-schools are?)
> 99% of visitors to the campuses exclaim upon entry that Only you guys could have created a miracle like this opposite Indore railway station.
Without even visiting the campus, you write nonsense about it dear Shreyam. What to say? Once again, why dont you please visit www.Proton.in especially the PHOTO GALLERIES ? Pictures dont lie, right?
Shreyam, why do you selectively fail to mention that PROTON is driven actively by a Top Team of 8 outstanding individuals listed below
Dr Manas Fuloria IIT Delhi, Harvard, Stanford Global manufacturing and operations expert
Chand Narayan XLRI, one of the finest HR professionals in India
Devashish Chakravarty IIM Ahmedabad Gold medalist (overall best student), one of the finest minds who also fought the Kargil war as an Indian army major
Vineeta Singh IIM Ahmedabad Gold medalist (overall female best student), one of the finest minds who is also a BTech from IIT Chennai
Bhushan Dabir IIM Ahmebadad , a great trainer, enterpreneur
Vishal Prabhukhanolkar IIM Ahmebadad , a great trainer, enterpreneur
Prof.Varun Gupta Youngest CS in India in 1992, great mentor with 20 years of experience
Sandeep Manudhane (myself) IIT Delhi 16 years of entrepreneurial & teaching experience

All these 8 individuals in flesh and blood teach and train students at our campuses. You have no idea what you are missing!
Yes it is a crowded place PROTON is located at. Opposite Railway station. But is is the heart of the city where is must have cost much more to build, right? Instead of acres of land in the jungles outside the city? There are strategic reasons for decisions taken at various levels that a brand reaches.
Do you realize that students save 3 hours EACH DAY because they do not have to commute to citys outskirts?
And finally, maybe students will benefit not by your inanities but by what these people had to say -- www.proton.in/testimonials/
Allegation / Half-truth -
3. they are not giving a AICTE recognized PGDM (equivalent to MBA) ...its providing its own PGP certification ( not recognised ) + MBA ( DISTANCE LEARNING PROGRAME) frm some Vinayaka Mission Univ. ( never heard of it)
Sandeep says Have we even once claimed that we are AICTE approved? Please show me where. PROTON proudly gives its own PGP and a DLP MODE DEGREE. So whats wrong with that if students join after ascertaining all facts? You surely cant mean to say that 800 Protons have joined us in less than 12 months since inception, without studying the facts? Please dont insult other students sense of judgement so brutally.
The only thing the Top Team of PROTON (in case you have read enough to be aware of them) focuses on is QUALITY OF EDUCATION. Nothing else.
Allegation / Half-truth -
4. Its charging exubarant fees which is not in the line with the infra n facilities.
Sandeep says Exubarant fees? Maybe you meant exorbitant fees. Well, we leave it to the students discretion to judge this. Honestly, if I were to put numbers to this argument, PROTON is not even charging half of what it should actually be charging for the quality it is providing. Sure, you will never agree, I dont want you to. The trust of my 800 students is more than enough for me. End of my submission!
Are you aware that more than 10% of our students come through merit scholarship route? Are you aware that we provide almost a mini-library to each Proton (all books in original, unlike photocopies given in several other b schools) ? Are you aware that the facilities you so worry about start from 7:30 am in the morning and last till 8 pm in the evening? Are you aware that Protons enjoy classic Movie Shows twice a week in the ultra modern Vivekanand Auditorium? Are you aware that physical fitness is an integral part of the curriculum at PROTON? Each student walks 2.5+ kms a day? And thats brisk walk making everyone sweat! Surely, these things are neither known to you, nor do they matter to you.
Once again, please visit www.proton.in/testimonials/ to discover the truth!
Allegation / Half-truth -
5. its not a residential prog.
Sandeep says When did we claim it is? Surely, this is an area we are working on. And I am sure, when our ultra modern hostel will be ready, with all its facilities, you will be ready to post another thread criticizing that such a thing is not possible at all.
Allegation / Half-truth -
6. They have 2 intakes .... and they admit ppl with grad % as low as 52% and some who to give their supplementary exams. ( i can name ppl )
Sandeep says Judging students only by their college exam percentage is a mistake we are committed not to making. You will understand its significance much later in life.
Allegation / Half-truth -
7. the id of ppl on PG are all common and have a similar format of posts ie. they say how rigorous MBA @ PROTON is ... what new company came to their campus .... how summer placments have been and all companies are biggies.... not possible for a year old B-school n that too in this time.
Sandeep says Is that so? Just because students praise their institute makes you doubt their integrity? I feel sorry for your loss that you could never attend an institute that could drive such level of loyalty in you.
Allegation / Half-truth -
8. Proton ppl can be seen marketing for PT outside CAT n various exams.

Sandeep says God bless you with the right IQ my dear! Practical training is our way of preparing students for the future. Surely, you wont know that.
I am just giving real n factual info which i can prove.
Pl think bfore joining. I AM JUST AN AWARE STUDENT.
Sandeep says Surely, think carefully before joining. Thats what most students in Indore and Ahmedabad did. So by the grace of God, love of students, and support of parents, PROTON campuses are running a good show at both locations.
PROTON is a positive movement. I wish you all the best!
www.proton.in/gallery/
www.proton.in/events/
www.proton.in/testimonials/

Hi everyone!

you are welcome to join us at PT universe campuses across India for a blood donation drive on 14th August 2009. This is part of our independence day celebrations!

At Indore, we are doing it at PT universe headoffice, at Yeshwant Plaza.

Contribute to a social cause. Celebrate independence!

thanks, Sandeep


Hi Sandeep,

Well a fitting reply for an immature remark over your institute. Every student, every teacher, every mentor, every entrepreneur and all the individuals has to have a marketing strategy of their own that I consider is an essential ingredient for a perfect career and a $$ rich life !!

I am not proton as of now, but still I abhor this century old ideologies which rely on a institute's infrastructure and other non eminent properties rather than its "core" faculty, the ideologies of its "core" members, the "vision" of the whole institute as an one individual.

Even Sultan Kosen of Turkey was once a few inches when he was born, but now he is officially the world's tallest living man standing at 8 feet 1 inches. Its NOT when you start, its JUST when you start.

I agree that proton is a new kid on the block, but like every other institution it has the ability, the ideas, the values and the vision to become best in the business.

all the best to you sir but, just a humble request, a man of your stature should not come to the rescue of a college, but its upto the students who can dent a person's hackneyed views with a similar fitting reply.

keep up the good work and the rest will follow suit.

Regards,
Rajat Sharma
Proud Indorian







6 comments:

  1. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  2. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Urge the blog maker to plz contact me asap...9893242929 .

    ReplyDelete
  4. ooo man do u even know to whom r u arguing he is SANDEEP MANUDHANE ..
    .
    .
    .nam hi kaafi h boss

    ReplyDelete
  5. Well shreyam I really feel you should have done some background research before accusing PROTON and Sandeep sir
    Frankly speaking I dont know much about Proton since I was not a part of it but let me tell you I have stayed in pt education for 2 months recently only in April....I have seen the amount of effort these people put in making notes,test paper series,teaching the students,keeping them up to date with whatever is happening around them(especially sandeep sir by his gk lectures which last for a minimum of 2 hours);they are always there to clear your doubts in class as well as personally

    ReplyDelete
  6. These people literally slog and work so hard....As far as the institute is concerned it's a huge place with I guess around 18 classrooms 2 auditoriums:everything air conditioned and as far as I have heard earlier the place was centrally air conditioned
    The location is perfect since its very convenient for the students...it is centrally located and everything is nearby.Moreover the amount of work they make you do you can't afford to waste time in commuting.
    As I said before I don't know much but presently the faculty of Pt Education(Sandeep Sir,Hemant Sir and Ram Sir) includes one of the finest people I have ever met in my life.
    Shreyam I hope all your doubts must have been cleared by Sirs comment...like I said:He is always ready to help people out and to clear all their doubts!

    ReplyDelete